Quickies
1 out of 5
Recommended: No
Categories: dystopian, easy reading, one-time reads
Review
The title misleads because this is not actually going to be a book review. Ladies, I read that book and let me tell you that I want so badly to write an absolutely scathing review. I want to whale into it and let everyone know just exactly why I dislike it. In fact, I did. I started to write a completely different review than the one I'm writing now.
I think now, though, that those righteous-rage opinions are best left unpublished.
I've written many negative reviews in the past. I've enjoyed writing them. I glory in tearing apart weak plots and cardboard characters and poker-stiff dialogue. As an aspiring writer, I'm quick to judge. I get angry when people like things that I personally consider poorly written and I burn to tell the whole world why they should never have been published.
But in those reviews my words aren't kind and, though my opinions are strong, they are critical and have the capacity to be hurtful. So as I planned my review for Divergent, I began to wonder why I had such a nagging sense that I shouldn't. I wanted to - very badly - but the more I wrote and thought about it, the more I felt that, as a Christian and a writer, I should shut up, live and let live. I took a break and gave it some thought and here's what I ended up with: is it really worth my time to throw my two cents into the pool of fans and haters and start a fire that isn't worth stoking? Will my words really do anything worthwhile?
No.
I can spend an hour or more writing a review that will turn people off or I can spend it more wisely writing something that won't polarize, criticize or draw lines. Those characters belong to someone who feels the way about them that I feel about mine. I may not agree with another author's writing style, I may question their motives and choices, I may be incensed by the fact that people find their work worth reading, but I don't need to give it voice. I'm entitled to my opinions, but unless they bring grace, I'm better off keeping them to myself.
So that's my review for Divergent. No, I wouldn't recommend it, but that's merely an opinion. Take it or leave it and form your own. :)
Till next time!
There is only one book I ever absolutely hated...it was a novel on l m Alcott.
ReplyDeleteWas it Fruitlands? Because I totally agree with you!
DeleteNot for sure...it was set during the summer before she left home
DeleteSo you did end up reading it! And while I respect your decision not to offer an in-depth review, I for one am grateful for the de-recommendation...now I definitely won't waste time on it. :)
ReplyDeleteI haven't read this book, so it's good to know it's not worth it. I know how easy it is to pull apart things you don't like, and I fall short there too; I commend you for writing this post. :)
ReplyDelete